Showing posts with label race. Show all posts
Showing posts with label race. Show all posts

Tuesday, 16 August 2016

Definitely Maybe

It is, several radio programmes and broadsheet articles inform us, twenty years since the 'Summer of Britpop'. I was there, young and music-loving. Comparisons with earlier golden ages are inexact; it can't have been like the 60s, since I can remember it. It involved, as I recall, inordinate amounts of Guinness combined with indelicate swaying to the dulcit tones of What's The Story Morning Glory. We weren't aware that it was the Summer of Britpop at the time. It was just summer, the school holiday. Nor did we, by which I mean my friends and myself, think there was anything especially epoch-making about the music we were listening to, or rather the music that was played at us, in pubs and clubs and on the radio; my own tastes were slightly more eclectic. It was alright, it was just there. We hadn't known any different. Nostalgia, however can transfigure the most quotidian of times, and so here we are, two decades on, keeping the anniversary of something called the Summer of Britpop.



There is something distinctly unsettling about people feeling nostalgic for periods within one's living memory. Nostalgia is always for people older than oneself. It is more a matter of not being able to get bananas in the war, or the electric tingle as a beehived girl rubbed against your chinos than of the Verve or David Blunkett. The jarring intimation of mortality repressed beneath the surface of this discomfort might go some way towards explaining why I have greeted public celebration of Britpop's birthday with a mixture of incomprehension and blind rage. So, when 6Music announced that they had made Oasis' Knebworth performance available on Iplayer, I tweeted this:

This perhaps demonstrated a temporary inability to think both sides of the question, but then age does funny things to you. A good proportion of my digital fury was entirely justified, but before we get onto the reasons for that the other side of the balance sheet needs addressing. The Britpop phenomenon, either in its musical origins or promotional narration (if it's even possible to disentangle the two), issued from a perfectly correct sense of the American dominance of rock and pop music, and a legitimate resentment of this. Even though there is a good case to be made that the Smashing Pumpkins were better than Suede, and in spite of the awkward fact that, like the mods before them, the Britpoppers could only respond to rock's wrapping itself in the stars-and-stripes by wrapping themselves in the Union Jack, there was something praiseworthy about the urge to kick back at the bigger country. There was too  a sense in which working class identity was cool within Britpop culture. This didn't necessary translate into working class people themselves being cool, nor did the working class identity that was enacted on stages and lauded in the NME commonly bear much resemblance to anything that would have been recognised by many inhabitants of that class. Still, compared to today's hipster scene, where one gets the distinct sense that working class people are regarded not as voguish aliens to be emulated nervously, but as Brexit-voting, commercial music listening, racists who wouldn't know a good craft beer if they tasted one, it wasn't so bad. These things are relative.

Britpop was also capable of voicing discontent in a more or less articulate fashion. Admittedly, it most often came down on the 'less' side, but it remains the case that the raw anger of 'Is it worth the aggravation/ to get yourself a job when there's nothing worth working for?' has a lot going for it. Gallagher's devil-may-care drawl voices a nihilism more conditioned than staged. Blur were capable of framing their protest in more explicitly political terms. Mr Robinson in his quango is 'the self-professed saviour of the dim right-wing'. Ernold Same was narrated by the man described in the CD insert as 'the right-on Ken Livingstone'. It turns out that Damon Albarn was the source of the band's occasional leftism. Dave Rowntree was meanwhile an enthusiastic supporter of New Labour and ultimately a cheerleader for invading Iraq. Alex James now divides his time between making artisan cheeses and hanging out with the Chipping Norton set.

Alas, Britpop was not simply well-meaning angst and sticking two fingers up to Uncle Sam. It was in other respects, as we learned to say later, problematic in many respects.  This probably wasn't what Adorno had in mind when he said that every tale of civilisation is also a tale of barbarism, but nor is that line entirely irrelevant here (even if 'civilisation' is an optimistic description of Country House, and 'barbarism' an unkind take on Menswear). Culture is a human product, and as such is tainted from the outset with the conditions of its production, which means amongst other things with politics. This much is evident in the very word 'Britpop', a musical subgenre defined as much as anything by the state from which it issued. In this it bears some resemblance to the earlier Krautrock, although the acts generally classified as part of the latter are universally more interesting than Ocean Colour Scene. In both cases, there is a politics to the identification. Germany at the time of Krautrock was not one, but two, states. Britpop, in spite of its name, was an overwhelmingly English phenomenon. The most obvious exceptions are at best borderline cases: the Manic Street Preachers pre-date the movement slightly, and never really fitted in culturally or politically. Catatonia were of the period, but I never recall thinking of them as being 'part of the same thing' as Blur and Oasis. This was, retrospectively, a compliment. Ash were admittedly Irish, but in the face of eight centuries of national oppression the misdescription of a rock band seems a slight matter.




Claiming English idiosyncracies as uniformly British is a national pastime. A peculiarity of British rock music has been, at least until recently, its celebration of a certain kind of imagined working class identity, coupled with the occasional elevation of working class people themselves to superstar status. Britpop satisfied this fetish enthusiastically. Oasis certainly were from working class backgrounds, and spoke in interviews about being on the dole. Blur were from more monied stock in at the time ill-specified parts of East London but spoke like the love child of Dot Cotton and Dick van Dyke's chimney sweep. This was class as a marketing method; the proletariat were in this season, just as ripped jeans had been a few summers previously. The working class as presented in the posters and at the gigs was a pastiche, packaged for quick consumption. It was a matter of cheeky smiles and the hint of attitude, without taking the latter far enough to be intimidating. You expected Damon Albarn to shout 'oi, get orf me barrow' at any point. What the working class as adapted for Britpop certainly didn't lower itself to doing was work. Whilst The Who, the band Oasis wanted to be when they weren't busy trying to be the Beatles, could make a film in which a young man gets away from the drudgery of London toil, only for the hero of a mod dance floor to be revealed as a bellboy, by the 90s five days of the week were almost entirely absent from British musical output. Oasis, quite reasonably didn't want to work (Eagleton describes this as a good reason to be a socialist), but lyrically it was mostly a matter of falling in love, falling out of love, taking drugs, being a rock and roll star, and - in the case of one Blur song - listening to the shipping forecast. Put like this it sounds not unlike the life of a full time rock singer. Imagination was not a notable feature of the period.

The band often counted as part of Britpop who were better on class, in every sense in which a band could be, were of course Pulp. They are exempt from my criticism,  but were never really part of Britpop. The band predated the phenomenon by a long way, and accidentally hit the big time on the back of it. I've written about them before here. Whether or not 'nobody loves a tourist' was aimed, consciously or otherwise, at what their musical contemporaries were saying or doing, it captures some of the truth of an era. Even more dispiritingly, it speaks also to subsequent eras.

Candida Doyle's role in Pulp also distinguishes them from the run of Britpop star acts, which whiffed of Lynx and testosterone. A blokish, cliched working class masculinity suffused the genre. There were female fronted bands: none of them got the headlines and the best known, Elastica, obtained that status not least because their lead singer was sleeping with Damon Albarn, which doesn't suggest that Britpop represented a feminist high point. The best, and most under-rated, of the bands insufficiently male to be canonised were Kenickie. Notable for having singing in a regional accent that was, on the one hand, neither Cockney or Mancunian, and on the other genuine, they were musically and lyrically excpetionally. Misleadingly naive in content, their songs communicate a reality airbrushed by the comic book capers of Albarn and Gallagher they had this in common with Pulp. Lauren Laverne's wilting voice on 'People We Want' captures a darker side to the Britpop era, boredom and anxiety combine as insecure, in spite of cocaine, a young woman wades through a night out as though it were quicksand. 'This life, it's taking too long', she sings; and you know what she means.



The fear that life might not be worth living is not one that haunts the male Britpop oeuvre. It is fundamentally upbeat, macho even - although not aggressively so: with the possible exception of the Gallagher brothers, Britpop frontmen presented as new men. This did not make them averse to the odd nod and a wink. This was the era of new laddism; young men were busy learning from Loaded magazine that what, to a casual observer, might appear like sexism was in fact both ironic, and empowering for women. The apparently contradictory nature of these claims seems to have passed by for these born again feminists. The masculinity of Cool Britannia was resolutely heterosexual. In this respect it was less diverse than any other significant rock movement for a couple of decades. Brett Anderson performed an ambivalent androgyny: yet Suede were John the Baptist figures for Britpop, teetering uneasily on the brink of the New Covenant, quick to diminish so that Blur, Oasis, and countless derivative acts could take to the stage. When the messiah came, he was butch. On one occasion Alex James wore an Oasis t-shirt on Top of the Pops. He might just have well sported the slogan 'I've got a bigger dick than Noel Gallagher'. The intensity of the gender retrenchment in 90s music was in many respects laughable, even though it reflected, and fed back into  a much more dangerous backlash against feminism in society at large. It would be a cold-hearted person indeed, however, who didn't laugh - and not in the manner intended by the authors - at the ridiculous spectacle of 'Vindaloo' competing with 'Three Lions' for the number one spot, as the cultural icons of the period jockeyed to demonstrate their authentic football-supporting laddishness. It has always been unclear to me which team Alex James supports, but then I don't follow Chipping Norton Swifts closely, so I may be missing something. We should, I suppose, be grateful that Keith Allen allowed his mum and his gran to share in the bucket of vindaloo.

Singing about Goan food might have been de rigeur, but too many English people have always been more comfortable with Asian food than with Asian people. Britpop was white in its makeup and its cultural reference points. This in itself communicated something about how Britishness was understood at the time. The period coincides, for example, with Asian Dub Foundation's first releases - far more enduring and musically interesting than anything sung at Knebworth all those years ago, yet never counted as part of Britpop. This is both an injustice and a liberation.

The simplistic image of a white, male, straight, salt-of-the-earth, urban, sexual but not threatening, impish but never straightforwardly rebellious, working class was tailor made for New Labour. A wave of populism and flagwaving ushered Blair through the Downing Street gates, riding high on the legacy of forgotten protest and ageing hope. Elected, in large part by a class (contrary to much speculation, there are in fact working class people in marginal constituencies, even in the south of England), he wanted to govern a mass. A heady mix of 'progressive' nationalism and condescending ordinariness spewed forth from government onto a society already drenched with the same concoction by its rock stars. This was a Britpop government. And the Blairites imagined that the working class was as contemporary rockstars presented it: monocultural, in many ways reactionary, white, but with a sense of fair play and fun. The result was as politically ambiguous as Britpop itself was culturally: it gave us increased public spending and ASBOs, a minimum wage and asylum detention centres, the Human Rights Act and the invasion of Iraq.

There's a reluctant admission on the part of their sometime supporters that the Blair/ Brown governments did not usher in the New Jerusalem. Yet even this is narrated in terms of the working class as imagined in the Britpop era. We hear a lot about the forgotten people of the period, as indeed we should, the betrayal of core supporters by New Labour in government was real and deep. Quickly, however, this shades into talk of the white working class, the need to understand traditional values, generations of male pride lost to unemployment, concerns about immigration - in every way imaginable real and urgent social and economic crisis is renarrated in terms of a backlash against the gains of the past two decades as regards race and gender politics. In this way we end up with Blue Labour and its lingering influence. Nostalgia for Britpop fits in perfectly with this use of an ideological construction of class to defuse the politics of class. From the perspective of this project the immediate enemy is an out-of-touch metropolitan obsessed with the politically correct agenda of earlier times and unaware of the concerns of ordinary, hard-working, people. His name is Jeremy Corbyn.

Twenty years have passed, then. Were it not for the remarkable elevation of a socialist to the Labour leadership, it would be tempting to say that the most notable change is that privately educated rock aficionados no longer feel the need to adopt working class accents. These are not times in which Etonians lack confidence. That, more than the whimpering of Owen Smith, ought to serve as a cautionary tale for left-wing ebulience.




Friday, 26 December 2014

Danczuk and the 'white working class'



New Left Project are running a series on race and class in Britain. It's deserving of a look. In particular, Jon Lawrence's piece, published today, Why the Working Class was never 'White', is excellent, and speaks to a particularly unhelpful idea that has currency in the labour movement. I quote the final paragraph:

The sooner we recognise that the ‘white working class’ is not a thing, but rather an unhelpful media construction which the left must eschew, the better. Not only does it deflect attention from the virulent racism in other parts of English society, but it reinforces the idea of working-class people as unchanging, anachronistic and ‘left behind’. The ‘racialisation’ of class in Britain has been a consequence of the weakening of ‘class’ as a political idea since the 1970s – it is a new construction, not an historic one, and it is profoundly unhelpful. It makes it all too easy for millions of people hit hardest by neo-liberal economics to be dismissed as somehow reaping what they deserve.
Upon reading this, I was reminded of Simon Danczuk. The voice of Labour's hard right in England, and a serial complainer - sadly against all the evidence - that the leadership don't say very much about immigration, Danczuk is also a self-proclaimed advocate for the working class and/ or 'ordinary people'. He considers himself to be part of the former, 'a working class MP'. It has to be said that, in spite of an impeccably proletarian background, his last job before entering parliament was as director and co-owner of a public affairs consultancy, but working class status is presumably supposed to be something like Catholic baptism, indelible.

The brand of populism Danczuk promotes combines a class rhetoric with a campaigning stance on tabloid-pleasing issues; he has been a prominent voice around the scandal of child sex abuse. A nostalgic, romantic, attachment to the constructed white working class of yesteryear co-exists in Danczuk's mind with an outright rejection of the kind of reformist mitigation of capitalism's worst excesses one might imagine to feature, 'Spirit of '45' style, in the narrative. The Blue Labour constituency, close to the Labour leadership, sell the purer product. For both, however, there is an old working class Labour following, which is understood as both racialised and racist. Until the 'legitimate' concerns of 'ordinary voters' are addressed, Labour will lose out to UKIP or abstention. There's an element of truth in this, as I've said before, but not in the way the purveyors of Hovis kitsch politics suppose.

How did this discourse come into its own? As Lawrence notes, it was the media and academics who constructed the white working class before it was seized on by politicians and entered into the nexus of cultural self-understanding. But an ideology must have some kind of purchase on truth, however perverse and one-sided, to get a grip on the hearts and minds of any significant number of people. Scientology is always likely to remain a niche pursuit. And the truth, of course, is that large numbers of working class people do feel left behind; large numbers of working class people do feel distant from a political elite. In both cases the feeling is entirely veridical: it's just that the 'white working class story' gets things wrong by supposing this estrangement has anything to do with skin colour.

Matters were not helped by the fact that there was a measure of social liberalism in the New Labour years - although not especially around the issue of immigration: increases in immigrant numbers resulted from the global economic and political context rather than the Blair-Brown governments, which were quite happy to leave asylum seekers languishing in detention centres, being a 'soft touch'. To the extent that a certain liberalism - over civil unions, for example - did co-exist, however, with the absence of any serious reformism in the socio-economic sphere, this helped to give rise to the 'Hampstead Heath politics' tale told by Danczuk. The concurrent demonisation of the working class, documented by Owen Jones and others, provided a context where it could be imagined that council estates were full of resentful xenophobes. Chavs were not only idle, they were racist. Think about how the average BNP supporter was imagined in the media - he or she had an Essex accent and probably the odd tatoo. She lived in a council flat, decked out with England flags. Polling data in fact suggests this character was far more likely to live in a relatively affluent suburb.

Danczuk is just taking the whole story full circle. Rather than turn up his nose in disgust at the reactionary proletarian of metropolitan imagining, he has set himself up as their champion. Much the same dynamic was at work around Emily Thornberry's forced resignation. The flag-waving cage fighter at the centre of that particular episode is a living caricature of the working class as projected from Westminster. Until a better class politics becomes articulate, expect to hear more about the white working class.

Tuesday, 28 October 2014

Swamped

Pause for a moment and consider why, amid the relentless targeting of immigrants to this country, a minister claiming that some UK towns are 'swamped' with EU immigrants is too much even for his Westminster paymasters. There is, after all, solid precedent for this kind of talk amongst leading Tories:



To say that we are swamped by something, is to imply that this thing is part of the non-human world. Flood waters swamp (note the language of floodgates that is never far behind talk of immigrants swamping). An office worker might be swamped by paperwork. That which swamps me is at once alien to me and something I want to do away with. When I say of people that they are swamping me I both 'other' them and to set them up as a legitimate target of hostility. And that - thanks to several decades of sustained anti-racist campaigning, these days so quickly dismissed as 'political correctness' - is no longer openly acceptable in their discourse of our leaders. Only irrelevant has-beens can now talk this way without censure.

Don't suppose for one moment, however, that this change in acceptable language reflects a change in heart. Those who thought that it was actually, as it were, wrong to treat immigrants as though they were so many pests to be exterminated would think twice before leaving them to die a hellish death in the Mediterranean.

Sunday, 10 August 2014

"God said to Abraham, kill me a son"

The Guardian is running this advert tomorrow:


The 'human shield' slander against Palestine has been dispatched elsewhere. The echoes of the historic anti-Semitic blood libel in the 'child sacrifice' claim have been noted. Let me, then, draw your attention to some lines from the advert:

More than three thousand years ago, Abraham had two children. One son had been sent into the wilderness and was in danger of dying. God saved him with water from a spring.
The other son was bound, his throat about to be cut by his own father. But God stayed the knife.
Both sons – Ishmael and Isaac – received promises that they would father great nations.
With these narratives, monotheism and western civilization begin. And the Canaanite practices of child sacrifice to Moloch are forever left behind by the descendants of Abraham.
Except they are not.
You may be unfamiliar with the Abraham story. Here's an interesting thing - on the Jewish and Christian version of the story, the one you'd find in the book of Genesis, the son who is not nearly sacrificed is Ishmael. So, if you like, the rejection of child sacrifice begins with the other son - Isaac, who is the father of Jacob (also known as Israel), and a foundational figure in the history of Judaism. Ishmael becomes associated with ethnic arabs and is an important figure in Islam (for whose characteristic traditions  Ishmael, rather than Isaac, is the son who escapes the knife).

Let me spell out the message here. One son - because these sons really stand for entire ethno-religious groups - has stopped killing its children. Over to you, the other son.

Or to put it more briefly: those Muslims, they kill their children.

This, apparently, is the kind of stuff that liberals think they should use their newspapers to disseminate.

Monday, 28 July 2014

Anti-Semitism is anti-Palestine

Look, I'm an anti-Zionist. I oppose the State of Israel, as I oppose in general the idea of a state being set apart exclusively for one ethno-religious group as racist. I support a secular one-state solution, the right of return for Palestinian refugees, and the peaceful co-existence of Muslims, Jews, and Christians in Palestine. I am, I take it, in no danger of confusing anti-Zionism with anti-Semitism.

But, to say that anti-Zionism is not anti-Semitism is not to deny the reality of anti-Semitism. And the sad fact is that some anti-Semites have attached themselves, like the racist parasites they are, to the pro-Palestine movement here and elsewhere. Sometimes the language of anti-Zionism gets appropriated, as with this delightful character, going on about "The Zionists, the Illuminati and Mr Rothschild himself, and the illegitimate child of Adolf Hitler!":




Other manifestations of anti-Semitism I've witnessed include:


  • Placards featuring stars of David, sometimes in association with swastikas.
  • Holocaust references.
  • Use of the phrase 'the Jews', when referring to the State of Israel, as in 'the Jews forced the Palestinians out of their homes'. Often this co-exists with classical anti-Semitic tropes such as bloodthirstiness or acquisitiveness.
  • A particular insistence that Jewish people condemn the actions of Israel more exacting than any similar insistence directed at the population in general.
These are all in and of themselves unacceptable, and deserve outright condemnation as racism. People saying and doing these kind of things should not be welcome on pro-Palestine demonstrations, and we should have the courage to confront them in the same way we would any other kind of racist. And that involves everything usually implied by the slogan 'no platform'.

Because not only are these things vile in their own right. They actively work against the Palestinian cause, providing a propaganda coup for Israel's explicit supporters as well as for those whose less honest and direct positions are effectively pro-Israeli (I have one well-known ultra-left sect in mind; I shall not give them publicity). It divides our movement and plays straight into the hands of those who would have us believe that diversity will always give rise to hostility.

Wednesday, 23 July 2014

Stop it, again

Right, here's the thing. The Russian government is really quite shit. To be specific, it is a homophobic shower of authoritarians serving a particularly brutal and oligarchic imposition of neoliberalism combined with an expansionist imperialism. This is Not Good.

It is not the kind of thing socialists should support. Really.

Said government is up to its neck in support for separatists in Ukraine, who almost certainly shot down an airliner causing massive loss of innocent life.

All of this is true. It is not some kind of imperialist lie. And, really, the combination of residual Stalinism and conspiracy theory wingnuttery on elements of the British Left that makes people claim otherwise both impedes our ability to understand the world properly and makes all of us look bonkers.

Stop it. Now.

(If you want more productive politics from the region, please do look at Ukrainian Socialist Solidarity).
------------------------

And here's another thing. Yes, obviously, Palestinians have a right to armed struggle. Tonnes of people have said that. But David Ward:

(a) is a Liberal Democrat MP. Enough said.
(b) has said clearly anti-Semitic things in the past. This provides the context to some of the reaction to him today.

Palestine needs friends. But it really doesn't need every friend that offers themself. Beware the thought that my enemy's enemy is my friend. Sometimes my enemy's enemy is simply a muppet


Monday, 26 May 2014

An Open Letter to Sadiq Khan




I know that you are bricking yourself after the Euro results. You are worried that Ed's not going to get into office, and that you're not going to get that red box you've always dreamed about. 

I understand that and I feel sorry for you.

We've all made mistakes in the past. I know I have.

I myself haven't put nearly enough effort into denouncing you and your friends for having sold out the labour movement to capital and for risking Labour's electoral fortunes by being generally useless.

But we can move on from our mistakes.

I can get better at denouncing you. And you can get better at not pandering to racists.

You say, to the working class voter imagined by your public school educated Progress intern with a bad sociology degree, that "immigration has driven down local wages."

I think I know what you mean. And I'm all for talking about immigration. I said so earlier.

But you know what? The only people who can 'drive' down wages are bosses. You can do something about that: you can support a statutory living wage. 

You can unshackle trade unions from Thatcher-era legislation. You can publicly talk about how racism is used to divide us, to the detrminent of everyone's pay-packet.

You're also talking about overseas people claiming Child Benefit and about kids in schools not being able to speak English.

Nobody else is doing that. Except the far Right. 

And there's absolutely no evidence that these are genuine, real, things in the world.

Please stop doing this.

Oh, and please start writing in paragraphs. We all mistakes, yadayada, but you just look stupid.


-----------

Original here


Friday, 23 May 2014

First thoughts on the great rush to UKIP

Some years back, one of the fifty seven different varieties of anarchist group that could be found within spitting distance of my then home in Hackney, put out an anti-BNP leaflet, consisting solely of the words "NICK GRIFFIN : POSH TORY TWAT".

There was, I want to claim, a wisdom in that verbal economy. If nothing else, the leaflet's authors recognised that simply running around shrieking "racist" and "fascist" at far-Right politicians is neither effective, nor gets to the heart of the motivations of those who vote for these people. These days, of course, Nick Griffin looks set to be consigned to the electoral equivalent of Hitler's bunker. And yet, the spirit of that anarchist leaflet finds new application. I give you Nigel Farage, former commodity broker, hard-line Thatcherite, and Arthur Daley impersonator:


At the time of writing, UKIP are making gains in Labour's north-of-England heartlands. And it's not just a northern thing. They have won a sufficient number of councillors in Thurrock to shift the council from Labour to No Overall Control. Those who have pointed out that UKIP has a working class electoral base, and those who feared the impact of this for Labour, stand vindicated already.

What to say about this? A few quick things.

UKIP : Racist Eurosceptic Tories

First, Nigel Farage is a racist. UKIP is full of racists. These things are true. Even the Sun thinks they are true. There is no harm whatsoever in saying them. Had Ed Miliband done so, it might have stopped a proportion of people voting UKIP. His equivocation on this basic point is initially puzzling, although not inexplicable (see Lenin here).

As I said a moment ago, mind, crying 'racist' isn't enough, and on its own would be counterproductive. Two other things about UKIP:

They are Eurosceptics. Whilst this, seemingly crucial, part of their stall took a back-seat to their desire to protect Britain from a surge of Romanian ne'er-do-wells in the campaign, it wasn't entirely absent. Witness the  flag poster,



Apart from looking like an album cover by a mid-90s Guns 'n Roses clone band, it's a reminder that the politics of Europe do actually feature in European election campaigns. A good number of people are not terribly happy with the EU. This is not universally because they don't like foreigners, or fear their good honest bacon and eggs being displaced by croissants: there's a sense of power being distant from them, of life being increasingly beyond their control. Now, I'd want to say a lot about this being primarily a result of capitalism, rather than the EU. But the latter is a tool of the former, the EU is not beyond criticism, and opposition to the EU is not intrinsically Right-wing. It's about time the Left started talking more about this issue. As your host suggested a while back.

Also, UKIP are Tories. Massive Tories. Nigel Farage is the economic equivalent of Nigel Lawson on crack cocaine. Within UKIP you'll find support for a flat tax, the dismantling of pretty much all employment protection and trade union rights, the privatisation of anything that moves, and opposition to the NHS. They have succeeded in this election in getting significant numbers of people who would never dream of voting for these policies if advocated by the actual Tories to vote for them. This is partly because their electoral opponents didn't tell the truth about UKIP's policies loudly enough; although, let's face it, it would be hard for Ed Miliband to push the 'arrrggg, UKIP support really bad austerity, which is likely to cause unemployment' line too hard given his own support for quite a lot of austerity. It is also partly because UKIP were savvy enough not to talk about their policies so much as about an out-of-touch political elite governing in their own interests rather than those of their voters. About this they were correct, even if they did carelessly fail to mention that Farage himself is part of said elite.

UKIP voters : neither racists nor stupid

So, then, we have established that UKIP are a bunch of arse. What to be said about their voters? This is surely the kind of question on which the liberal internet will have a subtle, nuanced, opinion. What says it?

Well, first of all. UKIP voters are bigoted, nasty, racist, xenophobic, sexist, homophobes. All of them. For instance:

Not only are there lots, and lots, and lots of convinced Nazis sprinkled throughout the towns and villages of Britain. No, for the panicked liberal narrative, the UKIP gains evidence the stupidity of voters. The brainless masses have come home to roost.

The Huffington post can be relied on usually to come out with this sort of thing; and it does not disappoint. And check this out:
Yes, that's right. Fear for the security of your job, or being in (what gets termed) unskilled work, makes you an excellent target for comedy. There's a strand of class hatred dressed up as progressive values running through the UKIP jokes. This is the 'chav' narrative rewritten for Guardian readers. It reminds me of nothing more than American liberalism, which sees itself as a bastion of educated civilisation against a redneck terror, and as a consequence plays straight into the hands of a populist Right which accuses it (correctly) of elitist metropolitan disdain for the mass of the population.

Making out that UKIP voters are basically just variants on Homer Simpson saves the bother of actually engaging with their fears and concerns, with the feelings of being ignored and of discontent with the status quo. It also avoids tackling the issue of immigration. Because, yes, no small number of people do see immigration as a threat. They are wrong, but they are not all signed up members of the Master Race. The Left can win arguments about immigration - we can talk about the use of low wages to divide workers on the basis of nationality, and we can talk about alternatives based on internationalism, solidarity, and levelling up. But we can't win arguments in which we don't engage. On immigration we've ended up talking only to those who already agree with us, and that leaves rich pickings for the likes of UKIP.


Disillusion versus smug liberalism

It's an unedifying choice isn't it? But it's one which not a few people felt themselves faced with.

Here be dragons, of course. The Blue Labour wing of the Labour Party - Glasman, Cruddas, and their cronies - will agree with pretty much all of the foregoing analysis. Their solution would, and in the coming weeks will, be the familiar cocktail of Family, Faith, and Tradition. This is a kind of homeopathic remedy for UKIP, a useless, diluted version of the real thing. As an attempt to reassert Labour's identity as a party of the working class  it fails not least because it is premised on ignoring those members of the working class who happen to be, say, women or members of ethnic minorities.

A socialist alternative, based not on getting a bunch of students and caring professionals to stand behind a, "Support Palestine. Defeat the Tories" stall on the High St once a fortnight, but on rootedness and hard work on estates and in workplaces, is really the only way to go. I can't say I'm optimistic, but we need a proper class-based, labour movement. I'll give the last word to Owen Jones,



Tuesday, 1 April 2014

That was a party political broadcast

...on behalf of anyone who isn't Tower Hamlets mayor Lutfur Rahman.




Yes, the BBC have being putting some of that much talked-about licence fee towards a hatchet job on one of Britain's most prominent Asian politicians in the run-up to May's election. Broadcast as last night's Panorama, the best they could get on Rahman was that he ignored the advice of council officers, and doubled council funding for Bengali run charities. The BBC join the dots for us telling readers of their website that, "Almost two-thirds of those who turned out to vote [last election day] were from his own Bangladeshi community."

One anticipates hearing next year that David Cameron has been returned as MP for Whitney by members of his "own white British community". 

Now, this should be a non-story. It is entirely correct that elected politicians be able to over-rule unelected officers. What does deserve comment is the glee with which some Labour figures have greeted the attack on Rahman. 


Two points here.

First, Rahman himself is correct. There is more than a hint of racism about Panorama's report. Labour should distance itself from the programme and refrain from using it if it doesn't want to be accused of putting short-term electoral gain ahead of basic anti-racist principle.

Second, the whole anomalous situation in Tower Hamlets is entirely the fault of the NEC, who removed the duly selected candidate in a fit of pop-Islamophobic frenzy.

Ken Livingstone stood as an independent and was subsequently readmitted to Labour, serving as a Labour mayor. The same approach should be adopted towards Rahman. The divisions in Tower Hamlets need healing, not deepening.

ETA: Dave Hill here is worth a read. As is Reuben Bard-Rosenberg here.


Friday, 28 March 2014

Graceless Islamophobia : Bashing the Archbishop



The nearest thing the British political blogosphere gets to a 'national treasure' is probably Archbishop Cranmer. Purveying a now quaint brand of Tory Anglicanism, a blog whose strapline is "examining politico-religious agendas with politico-religious objectives" doesn't immediately strike one as a recipe for success. However, Cranmer has a wide, and influential following. The denizens of Twitter play along with his habit of referring to himself in the third person as 'his grace', a nod in the direction of the dead theocrat whose name he has borrowed. Hold on, by the way, to the fact that Cranmer 2.0 is perhaps the only significant advocate in English politics for a tradition emphasising the identity of the State as religious, specifically Protestant -  a tradition whose bloody origins and historic advocacy of State-enforced religious uniformity cannot be entirely buried by any amount of tweeness. This awkward truth is not insignificant when assessing his grace's criticism of other religio-political traditions.

Anyway, I digress. Cranmer has an exalted fan club. His blog comes with a long list of approbations from MPs, bishops, and others (including a baffling imprimatur from the late Christian Socialist Movement). Not all of the reviews are entirely positive, it has to be said. Damien Thompson is quoted by the spectral archbishop as calling him "the ghastly Cranmer". Still, insults are signs of impact (nobody takes time out of their editorial schedule to ridicule the West Worthing Jigsaw Club) and there can be little doubt that Cranmer has impact.

This, to name the elephant in the room by jumping up and down very loudly shouting 'look, there's a bloody elephant', not withstanding the fact that his views on a whole range of topics are extremely nasty. Take his offering on Sayeeda Warsi and Sharia finance here.



Entitled "Baronness Warsi's Sharia priorities", the piece commences with a picture of Warsi in a hijab. I leave the semiotics of this to more qualified readers for analysis ("Beware, Here Be Muslamic things" is my best guess), he begins by noting Warsi's words after the meeting of a new Foreign Office group on Freedom of Religion and Belief:

Freedom of religion or belief is a personal priority for me. Across the world, people are being singled out and hounded out simply for the faith they follow or the beliefs they hold. The persecution of people because of their faith or belief has, I believe, become a global crisis. I want to make sure we have the best advice available. This is why we have set up this new Advisory Group, made up of real experts in the field, and of those who are working every day in practical ways to defend the right to freedom of religion or belief. I look forward to working with them as we seek to move towards a world where no-one is persecuted for what they believe.
The following day Warsi chaired a meeting of the Global Islamic Finance and Investment Group, a body concerned with the growth of sharia-compliant financial products which, if nothing else, is testimony to capitalism's thoroughly cosmopolitan potential. There are all sorts of interesting economic and financial questions around Islamic finance, but these do no detain Cranmer. She tweeted a lot about the meeting, which does seem to have upset him a little bit; it was certainly sufficient to bring out a sneering disdain for the Islamic, 'thank Allah that we're "Discussing how world finance centres can work together more closely to develop global #Islamicfinance market"'.

But the somewhat ironic irritation by a premier league blogger at the use of social media is only the hors d'oeuvre of outrage. Cranmer changes gear sharply,
His Grace can't help feeling that if Baroness Warsi exuded as much fervour and zeal about the persecution of Christians throughout the Middle East as she manages to conjure for sharia finance, HM Government might just begin to identify ways of alleviating the suffering, trauma and bloodshed that is occurring, as the Baroness observed last year, "on a biblical scale". It is utterly unacceptable that the only statement issued following the meeting of the Foreign Office group on Freedom of Religion or Belief was "Thought provoking". What are they going to do? When are they going to do it? How will foreign policy be geared toward the objective? 
Do not misunderstand my intention; the persecution of anyone (Christian or otherwise) by anyone else (Muslim or otherwise) is something that deserves attention, although that attention would be better focused if it were informed by an analysis of sectarianism which went beneath the surface of religiously-motivated persecution. The idea that religions just can't get along, or that one religion in particular is prone to oppress non-adherents, for all its shallowness serves a useful function in deflecting attention from the fragmenting effects on Middle Eastern societies of both military imperialism and struggles over oil wealth. That, however, is a left-wing commonplace. More interesting is the structure of Cranmer's rhetoric here. He has been talking about one issue involving some Muslim people, a discussion of Islamic finance, and has seamlessly shifted to another, the at once tragic and deeply complex reality of religious persecution. Baronness Warsi serves as a kind of middle term, simply by having jobs that require her to address both topics, but the deafeningly silent link is Islam. Cranmer echoes a standard line of Islamophobic thought: how come we are so accommodating to Muslims, when they are killing our brothers and sisters over there? What mugs we are.

An essentialised Islam faces down an equally essentialised Christianity. In this, and in many other ways, the Islamophobic Christian Right exactly mirrors the thought world of the most fundamentalist variants of Islamic thought. There need to be, for this particular bit of ideology to get a hold on our minds, such things as Muslim countries and Christian countries: in some sense every Muslim then needs to share in the guilt of countries coded as Muslim (there is an asymmetry here, of course, since Cranmer and his co-religionists are free to distance themselves from Western governments, and any suggestion that they share any kind of culpability for Fred Phelps or the Shankhill Butchers would be angrily dismissed. The situation regarding Muslims and such non-State agents as al Qaeda is, one imagines, less straightforward). This being so, the psychological stage is set for outrage on cue: why should they get mortgages when Christian coverts are in prison in Pakistan? This is only a question that makes sense within a certain ideological space, undermine that and it is as incomprehensible as asking why I am allowed to eat cake when there are cars parked on double yellow lines in Dalston.

For the slow-learner, the Christian-Muslim opposition is rendered explicit in the final paragraph:

And so the Baroness's Twitter feed becomes a metaphor for her real priorities: the pursuit of religious liberty is worth a photo-tweet and is "thought provoking"; sharia finance is worth a photo-tweet and a stream of tweets, with identifiable plans, opportunities, determination, tipping points, communications and a prime-ministerial speech. This, apparently, is #thoughtleadership, and in that Foreign-Office realm of faith, the suffering God is subject to Mohammed's Mammon.  
There you have it: this Muslim woman is crushing Jesus under the heel of the grasping Prophet. How dare she? The parallels with historic anti-Semitic discourse, by the way are fascinating: an opposition between Christian decency and the venal, worldly, Other, coming to a head at the Crucifixion.

 The use of the persecution of Christians as a lever for Islamophobia is by no means confined to the Cranmer blog. Consider the case of everyone's favourite retired right-wing Anglican bishop, Michael Nazir-Ali. It shouldn't need saying that it uses those victims as political fodder in a way that insults rather than expresses solidarity. It shouldn't need saying that it undermines efforts to do anything genuine to help these victims, not least by preventing a proper understanding of the causes of their plight. And it shouldn't need saying that it is the cassocked and surpliced outworking of the controlling ideology of the War on Terror. But, such are the times we live in, I felt the need to say those things anyway.



 His Grace sings Evensong

Wednesday, 19 March 2014

Budget Day, a pre-emptive slow hand clap



Well. it's budget day. Expect austerity. More of it. Expect the projection of heavily gendered moralising into the economic sphere by much agonising about 'working families' to the exclusion of lone parents. Expect to have to pay more for a pint or a packet of fags. And expect the Labour front bench to be just a tiny bit better than the Tories in a way that is more disappointing than reassuring.

What would social democratic reforms of a sort that make a difference and throw open debate look like? A favourite of mine is the land value tax. As a replacement for the Council Tax, it would put more money into the vast majority of peoples' pockets and, via its effect on land prices, put downward pressure on housing prices. Which can't be bad.

Also, increase benefits, tax the rich, and so forth.



 Edited to add (14:29): So I was wrong about the beer. But I find myself in pleasing agreement with Stella Creasy:


Nine million adults, by the way, have no savings. And, given that growth is predicted to fall in 2017/8, one might on tediously orthodox economic grounds wonder about the wisdom of massively incentivising savings in the manner that Gideon has done. Unless, of course, that wisdom is exercised in the cause of the already rich, with scant regard for anyone else. Perish the thought.

Inheritance tax waived for emergency workers killed in the line of duty? Populist nonsense. What, after all, is the rationale of not including others killed at work? It is tragic when a paramedic is killed (not that paramedics tend to leave vast amounts of wealth, but anyway). Is it less tragic when a train driver gets killed in a crash or a shop worker in a robbery? And what does this have to do with unearned wealth anyway? I note, by the way, that those killed by the police, a considerably bigger number than police officers killed in the line of duty, remain susceptible to inheritance tax. Not that the poor black people disproportionately represented in this group have much to leave.

The real question, of course, is how much of this crap Miliband and Balls plan to reverse.

Sunday, 16 March 2014

On what racism isn't

This from this thing of beauty


Who said this?

Racist jokes can be an important element in the development and maintenance of a cohesive, non-racist society.

Was it perhaps an unusually articulate piece of self-justification from Jim Davidson? Or an offering from Philip Blond or one of his henchmen?

Nope, it was a prominent left-wing blogger.

But he has an argument, here you go:

The concept of utani, a Kiswahili word of Arabic origin meaning something like ‘joking relationship’, encompasses  the complex social system of mutual inter-dependency between ethnic groups, who may pre-colonially have had warring a warring relationship around land and livestock, or who may have come into first contact via newly established trade route to the coast.  Utani was, in effect, a swiftly developed social structure that enabled different ethnic groups to cope with the massive changes brought upon them by the first wave of exploitative, international capitalism.
I take his word for it. But here's the basic problem, what he is describing are not racist jokes. They may be jokes about race. No doubt these can have the kind of socially galvanising effect Paul describes. On other occasions they might be rude, thoughtless, offensive, or whatever. None of this is racism. Racism is a structural relationship of power, which finds expression and is in turn reinforced by racist jokes (and many other things). A joke about race is racist just when a member of a dominant group tells it about a member of an oppressed group in the context of systematic group inequality. Which, let's face it, is exactly what we are talking about in Britain. In as much as namby, pamby, politically correct killjoys complain about racist jokes, which we do, it is because we do not want white people telling derogatory jokes about black people.

It is disgraceful to see somebody on the Left muddying waters that should be very clear. Because, in an odd way, Paul is right. Communities can be brought together by racist jokes. The problem is that it is the job of socialists to destroy those kind of communities and replace them with something better.

Wednesday, 1 January 2014

Coming over here

Just a quick one, before I return to the urgent business of Christmas leftovers.

Today the UK's borders were opened to Bulgarian and Romanian workers. The prolonged scream from the sewer press was to be expected, and needs to be seen in the wider context of a culture of political discussion of immigration conditioned by the challenge from the Right to the Tories by UKIP. Alas, the Labour front bench is part of the problem, witness David Hanson's comments reported today.

The response to all this from the internet Left has been an interesting one. The line seems to be that there is nothing too much to worry about, since not many Romanians and Bulgarians will come to the UK anyway. This point can be made by ridicule,

Or by fact-checking,
This last tweet echoes a campaign by the Southwest TUC. Example:



I suppose my worry about all of this is that it seems to inhabit same framework of debate as the Right. If there were lots of Romanians and Bulgarian workers coming to Britain, there would be a problem.

For a long time a good few people have been saying that the Left needs to talk about immigration, and not leave the field wide open to racists, whether besuited or boneheaded. That is true. But I think it matters how we talk about immigration. I'm not convinced at the moment that we're all free from our opponents' assumptions.