Showing posts with label The Left. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Left. Show all posts
Thursday, 27 August 2015
Take off the tinfoil hat
Sometimes I wish the world was run by a secretive elite. If it was, it would be a lot more interesting than it in fact is. There is a certain romance in believing one is facing down Bond-villains, nestled away in shadowy bunkers, in which they feed disloyal acolytes to crocodiles. This romance is lacking in Michael Gove. In fact not a single one of the British ruling class lives up to the standards of proper archetypical evil. They don't have lairs, they have villas in Tuscany. And not one of them has ever bitten the head off a live chicken. Although at a push Prince Philip has done this to a swan. We are, alas, doomed to mediocre malice in our rulers.
Nor, it has to be said, are this crowd especially secretive. Take the Conservative Party. They stood for election saying that they were going to impose massive cuts and attack trade unions. And having won the election they are proceeding to do just that. They may be bastards, but they are not sneaky bastards by any stretch of the imagination.
Perhaps it is a desire for a bit of excitement that drives 25% per cent of Corbyn supporters to believe that, contrary to fact, the world is run by a secretive elite. Like crazed lefty adrenaline junkies that these comrades of mine clearly are not content with nationalising the railways; they hope that they have to fight the CIA-Zionist-Lizards to do so. I'll come back to the 'Zionist' bit of that, since there's a darker side to all this conspiracy theory stuff.
'Conspiracy theory' - that's right. A striking feature of the 21st century left, which no doubt reflects a wider trend in our society, is the prevalence of so much conspiracy theoretic murk. I challenge you to go to more than a couple of demos without encountering some excitable character in a Guy Fawkes mask talking about the New World Order. If you're lucky, they might hand you a typewritten leaflet all about it. More mainstream, but in perpetual danger of slippage into conspiracy-talk, is the idea that there is an all-pervasive thing called 'the establishment' - the category, popularised by Owen Jones, has all but replaced the older, more nuanced, language of class and the state on much of the broad left. Put 'the establishment' together with an emotive topic like paedophilia, as recent news stories have done, and the crowd go wild - the number of supposed 'revelations' on this topic I've seen shared on left-wing social media is genuinely disturbing. Meanwhile the near-paranoid sense that everything is done with an ulterior motive has led numerous people to know better to support Julian Assange's attempt to avoid rape charges, on the basis that 'they' are out to get him. Indeed, the popularity of Wikileaks on the left -- the project in fact has its origins in the libertarian right -- is largely owing to the desire to know what they are hiding from us.
The striking reality of capitalist society, on contrary, is that everything is done in the open. I'm not denying, of course, the sordid reality of secret police forces and backroom deals. But the basic business of exploitation, the key structural features of the kind of society we inhabit: it's all out there in the open for everyone to see. The world is run for profit and proudly wears that fact on its sleeves, even as CEOs and Prime Ministers alike speak aloud about the need to reduce labour costs. In as much as this world is sustained by illusions, they are remarkably egalitarian illusions. The CEO and the bond trader, just as much as the shop worker and the pensioner, invest markets, currencies, and other creatures of our making, with an agency independent of the humanity that fashioned them. If you like, the system itself produces the illusions. The only secret is that there is nobody pulling the strings: we are not dealing with puppets, but with automata. The upside to this sorry state of affairs is that we are capable of distancing ourselves from it and stating the truth of the matter. As I just did.
That last paragraph is a standard old-fashioned leftist response to conspiracy theory. Why does it no longer convince a good number of people on the left? Partly, I think because, contemporary capitalist societies move at such a dizzying pace that peoples' experience of their lives is utterly disorientated and piecemeal -- the idea that 'They' are behind it all can be oddly comforting in such circumstances: there is an ultimate order and purpose, even if it is hostile. The Lizards are a Calvinist God for an unbelieving age.
Then there's the spectacular own-goal that was postmodernism. More than a generation of left-wingers have been schooled, with varying degrees of success, in the idea that reason, evidence, and the normal criteria by which we, as responsible agents, choose between competing accounts of the world are nothing more than veils worn by power. They are certainly not guides to objective truth, not least because there is no such thing as objective truth. The case for this view, which on the face of it renders any attempt at emancipatory theory and practice self-defeating, has been helped along by the fact that a certain kind of rearguard academic reaction certainly does appeal to Reason to bolster its own dubious interests. The name 'Richard Dawkins' suffices here to gesture in the direction of what I mean.
Then of course there was the decline of Marxism. In part this has to be attributed to the welcome collapse of the vile regimes that claimed it as their creed. But it's not just that: after all, there is a proud tradition of anti-Stalinist Marxism. Partly it's down to postmodernism. But whatever the full reason, one searches in vain on the left for a coherent, rigorously argued, account of the world which explains events and injustices not simply in terms of individual agency, but in terms of a social whole that - far from being shadowy - is amenable to critical scrutiny. Instead we have individual campaigns, united by nothing other than anger, often couched in moralistic terms (the moralism of the contemporary left; that's a whole other blogpost...) It's a volatile brew of raw emotion, indignation and confusion. Rich pickings for conspiracy theory.
This wouldn't matter so much were conspiracy theories not utterly disempowering. If They really are pulling the strings; what can we do? If we are being kept in the dark by networks of baffling complexity, what response is there other than fear? Perhaps the best we can do is search Google, looking for clues, trying to find out about Them. It's an atomised, self-enclosed, self-reinforcing way of 'finding out' about the world, which slides easily into genuine paranoia. Contrast this with the Marxian insistence that we learn about the world through collective engagement with it, seeking to change it and reflecting together on our efforts.
Then there's the anti-Semitism. The Rothschilds, the Zionists, Goldman-Sachs: the cast list in some of the accounts is tediously familiar fare. Living, as we still do, in the aftermath of a capitalist crisis focused in the financial sector, and blamed somewhat simplistically and moralistically on 'the bankers', the ground is fertile for the anti-Jewish tropes that run deep through the Western cultural unconscious to surface. And not nearly enough is being done to stop that.
Saturday, 28 March 2015
Judith's point is very valid...
I have just spent an exhilarating day with comrades in Thanet campaigning against Nigel Farage and for his Labour opponent. When one has been exposed to real politics, to racism and its interaction with other issues in the lives of real women and men, it is always a little dispiriting to return to the bosom of that most self-hating of beasts, the British left. But despise it though I sometimes do, it is home, and so I dutifully logged in to my computer this evening to find - would you believe it? - said left fighting itself.
The issue is that Socialist Resistance, a fourth internationalist outfit, has hosted a debate between feminists who take differing views on transgenderism. In response a petition has been set up, signed by some quite prominent leftists, and not a few men (there's, as you might imagine, an overlap between these two groups) criticising SR for hosting 'transphobes'.
As will rapidly become clear I do not think my views on this issue matter very much. Questions around transphobia are current on the left. For what its worth, I get the impression that people talk past each other quite a lot on this subject (for example, around the question of who qualifies as a woman, differing positions on which seem often to turn on differing prior definitions of the word) - this is exactly the kind of situation I would expect to be helped by open debate. There does also seem to me to be an almost perverse desire taken by some on the left, and I'm thinking here of cis-gendered straight people, to take delight in 'calling out' people as transphobes. I'm not talking here about Julie Bindel and her odious ilk, no - it seems quite easy to be a transphobe. Believing, for instance, that people suffer oppression on the grounds of sex, as distinguished from gender, seems sufficient. There's an uncomfortable whiff of thoughtcrime here, as well as hints towards more general issues on the left: an individualistic moralism and a hyper-identification with victims that seems to me to say more about those doing the identifying than it does about oppression.
I might, however, be wrong about all of this. It's not an area I've thought a great deal about. But even if I had the surprising certainty other male leftists seem to have about matters close to the heart of others' identity (this, if anywhere, is surely somewhere we should tread gently, for we step on dreams, and much else besides) I would not sign the petition. Nor would I sign a counter-petition. And the clue here is in the adjective 'male'.
I am a man in a patriarchal society. Let's, to reappropriate a phrase from John Major, get back to basics. Men, as a group and as individuals, benefit from women's oppression. Yes, it ultimately impoverishes us, much as the wage-relation ultimately alienates the bourgeoisie. But we, like them, do well in penultimate terms. We get more chances in life, we tend to get privileges in relationships - because patriarchy runs deep; like original sin, it inscribes itself into our very being, a being much of which is hidden from us at any given time. We cannot take ourselves out of this situation by a sheer act of will; one no more becomes a 'new man' by a virtue of a momentary decision than the flirtatious born again Christian is miraculously delivered from libido. I think that we have all, pretty much certainly, not only benefited from, but contributed to, women's oppression at some time or other, even whilst declaring ourselves feminists. This stuff is structural; that is not to say there is nothing we can do as individuals. It is to say that the fight against patriarchy must be a political affair.
And as a political affair, it ought to be guided by a principle that - one might naively have hoped - is part of the (non-Stalinist) socialist's ABC. The liberation of oppressed people must be the act of the oppressed themselves.
Which is to say, amongst other things, that men could usefully shut the fuck up about a debate within feminism, all sides of which are already well-represented among women. There is, to my mind, something particularly distasteful about men appearing to want to silence, or at least deny, a platform to a woman (with whom, it should be noted, another woman taking an opposing view was happy to debate). Just stop it.
Sort out the way we as individuals relate to women, in our relationships, in our workplaces - there is plenty of work to be done here. Offer support and solidarity where appropriate - of course. But acting as referees or censors to feminism? That is not our task.
Friday, 19 December 2014
Birchall on the SWP crisis
I used to have a soft spot for the SWP. In spite of growing up in a left-wing family, and having left home already a Labour Party member in a pretty hard-left CLP, my first exposure to Marxist ideas outside the printed page was through conservations with SWP members at university. I used to attend SWSS meetings, and people from the group would take me along to demonstrations and rallies. The Cliffites served as socialist babysitters for a small-town boy in a big city, and I remain grateful to them for an education and a welcome, although I remained in Labour. A good number of SWP members are people of whom I'm personally fond.
The party's intellectual traditions are an important bequest to the wider Left. In particular Tony Cliff and Chris Harman will remain essential reading for many years to come. The state capitalism analysis of Stalinism was, in my view, a step forward and has a renewed relevance in a post-Cold War context, where 'it didn't work in Russia' is easily the most frequent objection to communism. Organisationally, the SWP and its predecessors played a central part in many struggles. The Anti-Nazi League, in particular, stands out as an achievement.
For these, and many other reasons, it's impossible to take pleasure in the SWP crisis, and subsequent splintering of break-away groups, quite apart from the appalling treatment of women that heralded the schism. Whilst I am certainly not of the 'ban the SWP' tendency that is bringing a new intolerance to university campuses at the moment, the whole episode is a sobering reminder of the persistence of sexism on the Left. At the same time, it has weakened the Left collectively and threatened the vital heritage of the IS tradition.
There is no better account to be had of the crisis than Ian Birchall's recently published one. I commend it to you. But I do do with a word of caution: those of us who read it as observers rather than participants will, if we are honest, recognise echoes of the problems Birchall identifies in the SWP throughout the British Left. If any good can come of the past few years, it will consist in us learning and changing.
Sunday, 13 July 2014
Beyond the margins
I have not read Laurie Penny's latest book. This blogpost needs to start with that disclaimer. Nor do I have any interest in giving succour to the Penny-bashing industry. I was, however, intrigued by this review of Unspeakable Things.
This passage in particular captures well the attitude of much of the new Left:
...Her constituency, she says, is the underclass – gay and transgender people, goths, sex workers, rioters, anarchists – arguably the people with the most to lose from the neoliberalist (sic) agenda.Now, I would want to quibble with this reckoning of late capitalism's worst victims. I severely doubt that anyone ever finished a sixteen hour shift in a Chinese factory only to sigh "well at least I'm not a goth anarchist, that would be really terrible". But what is striking is the gap between this view, that sees the margins as the most politically fertile site, and the view of a Marx, who viewed socialism as "the movement of the immense majority in the interests of the immense majority". Marx was, on this as on much else, correct. Any socialism which does not arise from, and engage with, a social majority will end in either failure or tyranny. The 20th century gave us plenty of experience of both.
To say this is not for one moment to downplay the role of marginalised groups and cultures in the formation of a viable Left. As I see it, though, the role of socialist politics is to forge bonds of solidarity between these groups and a movement of the immense majority (not least, of course, because the groups are not disjoint: some workers are LGBT etc.). The margins are not a great place to be. They are, well, marginal. In fact, one of the worst features of capitalist patriarchy is its continual creation of margins, of new ways of excluding people.
All of which, given capitalism, is a roundabout way of urging that we don't ignore class. The working class, in all its diversity, fragmentation, and recomposition, remains the only collective agent with both the potential strength and the interest to move humanity beyond capitalism. Much though it might be easier to win a collective of student activists over to anti-capitalism, the task that matters is winning over the people on the tube, most of whom are not signed up leftists, and many of whom are not really that marginal. All of this requires patient, hard work, and isn't the least bit exciting or sexy.
Anyway, here's Herbert Marcuse on the old new Left. The first time as tragedy:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



