Wednesday 12 April 2017

Egg-gate

I resist the description of myself as a Christian Socialist. I am, rather, a socialist who happens to be a Christian, or a Christian who happens to be a socialist. My point is that I don't think there is a particular type of socialism for Christians. There is just socialism, towards which one might well be motivated by Christianity. In any case, I am suspicious that the designation 'Christian' has functioned historically to drive a wedge between Christian Socialism and the ungodly forces of Marxism. Whereas I think we need a good deal more Marx in the mix.

Nevertheless sometimes Christian identity does insert itself into political life. In a case of life imitating art (the art in question being The Day Today) Theresa May broke off last week from a busy schedule of cosying up to torturers and tyrants to bemoan the fact that the National Trust and Cadbury's had dared to advertise an egg hunt without using the word 'Easter'.



That was laughable. Other attempts to hint at anti-Christian discrimination, and to respond to it by reasserting Christian identity, are considerably less so. Britain First has mounted Christian patrols and harassed Muslims with the assertion that Britain is a "Christian country". One suspects this concern for Christianity is denominationally partial; my Catholicism is unlikely to pass muster, still less the faith of a black-majority Pentecostal church.

As with Theresa May's egg crusade, the fascists' claimed championing of a 1st century Jewish political prisoner is short on detail. Is the Jesus of John's gospel, who claims that his kingdom is "not of this world", the inspiration for the idea of Christian Britain? In these days before Easter, are we to reflect on the passion narratives and their portayal of religious and political authority brutally murdering a man who has opposed social barriers and staged a religio-political protest in the Temple? These are are not themes designed to fit into the Conservative Party conference.

In the same way as Christmas, Easter is a problem for political power in Britain. It is a symbolic resource which can be presented wrapped up in nostalgia and fellow-feeling. If kept vague and unthreatening, a certain amount of religiosity around it can bolster the current vogue for backward-looking conservatism - weren't things better when we believed? But the content of it as a religious festival is at best dubiously helpful to the political right. As a Catholic Worker once put it to me, "the Resurrection is an act of civil disobedience. When the state kills you, you're supposed to stay dead".

Now you, readers, may well have no time for any of this. But still, the thought behind the celebrations of the next few days is that the meaning of human history is disclosed by a battered body, that in order to gain life one must lose it. In order to rise again, for this creed, one must die. Marx says something similar about the international proletariat.

No comments:

Post a Comment